Сөз бостандығын қорғау халықаралық қоры
Международный фонд защиты свободы слова
The International Foundation for Freedom of Speech Protection

STATISTIC of violations of rights for freedom of expression in Kazakhstan. January- June, 2017

27 july 2017


 CONVICTED, ARRESTED AND IMPRISONED JOURNALISTS —11

 

Amangeldy Batyrbekov, chairman of the public association "Adilet", Shymkent, South-Kazakhstan region

A.Batyrbekov was sentenced to two years of restriction of liberty under Art. 411 - Defamation against a judge, juror, prosecutor, pre-trial investigator, expert, bailiff, judicial custodian.

He was released from custody in the courtroom on January 19. A.Batyrbekov was under house arrest since 08 June 2016.

 

Biggeldy Gabdullin, chief editor of CentralAsiaMonitor and director of Radiotochka website, Almaty

On January 24 ht was sentenced to five years of restriction of freedom on charges of extortion and released from arrest in the courtroom

B.Gabdullin was detained on November 15, 2016, and arrested with the sanction of the court on November 16, 2016.

 

Zhanbolat Mamay, "Tribuna. Sayasi Kalam”, Almaty

On February 10, the chief editor of the newspaper "Tribuna. Sayasi Kalam" Zhanbolat Mamay was detained, and on February 11 was arrested for two months with the sanction of the court within the frameworks of the investigation of embezzlement of BTA Bank by Mukhtar Ablyazov. On February 20 the Almaty City Court dismissed the appeal of Zh. Mamay and refused to change the pre-trial restriction from arrest to bail.

On March 31 the court extended the arrest of J. Mamay till May 10, 2017.

On April 27 the court extended the arrest of J. Mamay till June 10, 2017.

On May 31 the court extended the arrest of M. Mamay till July 10, 2017.

 

Teymur Akhmedov, Astana

On January, 18 Teymur Akhmedov was detained by the Committee of National Security officers on suspicion of inciting religious hatred by a group of persons. Later, the court sanctioned the arrest of Akhmedov for two months.

On May 2, 2017 he was found guilty in inciting religious hatred (Article 174 of the Criminal Code of the Republic of Kazakhstan) and sentenced to five years in prison.

On June 20  the Appeals Board upheld the verdict.

 

Asaf Guliyev,  Astana

On January, 18 Teymur Akhmedov was detained by the Committee of National Security officers on suspicion of inciting religious hatred by a group of persons. Later, the court sanctioned the arrest of Guliyev for two months.

On February 24, the court sentenced Asaf Guliyev to five years of restriction of freedom taking into consideraton his confession of guilt and repentance.

 

Yerlan Kaliev, Askhat Bersalimov, Galym Agelev, Almaty

On February 23, human rights activist Yerlan Kaliyev was detained at the exit from the office of the Kazakhstan international bureau of human rights and rule of law and taken to Alatau district police department for his intention to hold a single picket in defense of Zhanbolat Mamaym in front of  the Almaty department of the Committee of National Security.

Blogger Askhat Bersalimov and human rights activist Galym Ageleuov were detained at the site of the planned picket. According to G.Ageleuov, he arrived to the place of the picket to inform the others about the detention of Y.Kaliyev.

On February 23, the Almaty Specialized Interdistrict Administrative Court found civil activist Askhat Bersalinov guilty of violating the legislation of the Republic of Kazakhstan on the organization and holding of peaceful assemblies, rallies, marches, pickets and demonstrations and ordered him to be administratively arrested for 15 days. On February 28, the appeals instance left the ruling of the administrative court unchanged. The activist was released on March 10.

 

Kuanysh Bashpayev, Ekibastuz, Pavlodar region

Master student of the Islamic University of Medina of Saudi Arabia Kuanysh Bashpayev was under arrest with the sanction of the court since October 2016. On 7 April 2017 Pavlodar court No. 2 sentenced him to 4.5 years in prison on charges of inciting religious hatred (Article 174 of the Criminal Code of the Republic of Kazakhstan).

 

Max Bokaev, Talgat Ayan, Atyrau city

On November 28, 2016, court No. 2 of Atyrau found civil activists Max Bokayev and Talgat Ayan guilty in spreading deliberately false information during public events (Article 274, part 4, paragraph 2 of the Criminal Code of the Republic of Kazakhstan), incitement of social, national, tribal , racial, class or religious discord "(Article 174, part 2) and violation of the procedure for organizing and holding meetings, rallies, pickets, street processions and demonstrations" (Article 400). The court sentenced them to five years of imprisonment with serving their sentence in a general-regime colony and ban for public activities for three years.

On January 20, 2017, the Appeal Board of the Atyrau Regional Court upheld the verdict.

On 13.04.2017, the Supreme Court denied to consider the convicts’ cassation appeal.

 

Threats to journalists – 1

AkmaralShayakhmetova (UralskayaNedelya, Uralsk)

 

Attack on journalists – 3

Mirlan Amanzholov, Aliya Orazai (TC “Kazakhstan-Aktobe”, Aktobe oblast), NUR.KZ (Aktobe);Aray Temirkhanova and Ilya Rybin, (TC “31 Channel”, Astana), Ramazan Yesergepov “Journalists in trouble” (Almaty).

 

Closure/suspenson of media

 

Radiotochka.kz (Almaty, closed upon decision of the administrations of the Internet-portal)

“SayasiKalam. Tribuna”, Almaty (closed due to the closure of the newspaper’s owner enterprise)

 

 

Unjustified blocking and restriction of access to network editions —  7

 

Avaaz.org; http://tribunakz.com/ (Almaty); pana-defenders.info; nethouse.ru; channel of activist A. Shaigumarov (Uralsk) in Youtube and channel of blogger Ainur Kurmanov (Almaty) in Youtube; Foreignpolicy.com (USA)

Impending legal journalistic activity - 22

 

CRIMINALPROSECUTIONSANDCHARGES — 35  charges

Article of the Criminal Code of the Reoublic of Kazakhstan

Total

Of them by the courts

Quantity

Persons

Sentences

Art.. 130 (part 2 and part 3). Libel

 

Art.. 131 (part 2). Insult

13

10

Zhanna Bogatyreva (Kostanay region)

16.02.2017 – guilty verdict

Nikolay Kravets, news agency "Tengrinews" (Karaganda)

29.03.2017 – proceeding closed on applicatin of the private prosecutor about the termination of criminal proceedings

Marat Dauletbaev

(Baikonyr, Kyzylorda region)

 

09.02.2017 – guilty verdict.

14.03.2017 – the verdict came into legal force

Berik Zhagiparov

(Zhezkazgan city)

 

14.06.2017 – released from criminal liability in connection due to the reconciliation of the parties.

Alima Abdirova, Public Foundation "Aruana" (Aktobe)

Olga Klimonova, KIBHR 
(Aktobe)

 

20.06.2017 found not guilty

Galina Vologodskaya, "Kazakhstanskaya Pravda" (Ust-Kamenogorsk)

 

Malik Mahamdinov (Almaty) - 130, 131 CC

Abdulzhon Barayev - 130.131 of the Criminal Code

(The Republic of Uzbekistan)

2.06.2017  – acquittal on libel and insult..

Petr Pastushenko 
(Kostanay) - 131 CC

 

Art.147. Illegal collection of information about the private life

1

1

Nikolay Kravets, news agency "Tengrinews" (Karaganda)

 

Art. 411. Defamation of prosecutor

1

1

Amangeldy Batyrbekov, chairman of the public association "Adilet" (South-Kazakhstan region)

19.01.2017 – guilty verdict

29.03.2017 – the verdict remains unchanged

Art. 419 . Knowingly false report

1

1

Amangeldy Batyrbekov, chairman of the public association "Adilet" (South-Kazakhstan region)

19.01.2017 – found not guilty

Art. 274 Dissemination of knowingly false information

2

2


Max Bokaev, Talgat Ayan (Atyrau city)

 

28.11.2016 – guilty verdict

20.01.2017 – the verdict remains unchanged

13.04.2017 – the Supreme Court denied to consider the convicts’ cassation appeal

Art. 174 The incitement of social, national, tribal, racial, class or religious discord

12

8


Max Bokaev, Talgat Ayan (Atyrau city)

 

28.11.2016 – guiltyverdict

20.01.2017 – theverdictremainsunchanged

13.04.2017 – the Supreme Court denied to consider the convicts’ cassation appeal

Asaf Guliyev (Astana)

02.02.2017 - guilty verdict

Sanat Dosov (Aktobe)

27.12.2016 - guilty verdict

15.02.2017  (appeal) – the verdict remained unchanged

 

Ruslan Ginatullin (Pavlodar)

14.12.2016 г. – guilty verdict

02.02.2017 – the verdict remains unchanged

 

Teymur Akhmedov (Astana)

02.05.2017 – sentenced to 5 years of imprisonment for incitement of religious discord.

20.06.2017 г. – guilty verdict remains unchanged

 

Kuanysh Bashpayev

(Ekibastuz city,

Pavlodar region)

 

7.04.2017 sentenced to 4,5 years of imprisonment for incitement of religious discord.

 

Nariman Seitzhanov

(The city of Kokshetau)

 

9.06.2017 sentenced to 5 years of imprisonment

Art. 400 Violation of the procedure for organizing and holding meetings, rallies, pickets, street processions and demonstrations

2

2

Max Bokaev, Talgat Ayan (Atyrau city)

28.11.2016 – guilty verdict

20.01.2017 – theverdictremainsunchanged

13.04.2017 – the Supreme Court denied to consider the convicts’ cassation appeal

Art. 194. Extortion

1

1

Biggeldy Gabdullin, editor-in-chief of CentralAsiaMonitor and Radiotochka.kz (Almaty)

24.01.2017 - guilty verdict

Art. 218.  Legalization (laundering) of money and (or) other property obtained by criminal means

1

 

 

 

Art. 433. Disclosure of pre-trial data

1

 

 

 

Art. 430. non-compliance with court decision

1

 

 

 

 

CIVIL CLIAMS TO MEDIA AND JOURNALISTS–   49;

including

claims and lawsuits on protection of honor, dignity and business reputation - 48

Claimed amounts of compensation for moral damage - 163 million 60 thousand tenge.

Collected compensation for moral damage  - 51 mln. 720 th. tenge

Appelants of civil claims to media: civil servants - 10 , Legal entities - 15, citizens - 21

Judgments rendered - 33 (Incl. 7 - in the appeal). Of those in favor of the media and the citizens - 20.

Judgements passed–  33 (icluding 7 in appeal bodies). Of them in favor of media and citizens– 20.

 

PERSECUTION BY ADMINISTRATIVE ORDER  – 3

 

denials and restrictions in providing socially important information —  86

Ask your question